Who would you consider the Carindals All Prospect Lineup?

[JoeMcKim]

Who is the best players at each position in the Cardinals entire minor league system?

All I got so far:

SP. Shelby Miller
RP.
C.
1B. Matt Adams
2B. Kolten Wong
3B. Zack Cox
SS. Ryan Jackson
OF. Oscar Taveras
OF.
OF.

[Socnorb11]

I'd probably put Swagerty in the bullpen.

[JoeMcKim]

Good thing about most of these guys is they'll be starting the season in Memphis, just 1 promotion away from the majors for Miller, Adams, Jackson and Cox.

[jerbyrd25]

Good thing about most of these guys is they'll be starting the season in Memphis, just 1 promotion away from the majors for Miller, Adams, Jackson and Cox.

With Cora, Velez, and Kozma and potentially Greene or Descalso being in AAA also, I doubt R. Jackson starts in AAA, although I really hope he will.

He did play in the AFL so that's a plus.

Also, wouldn't Cox be blocked by Carpenter if he doesn't make the opening day roster?

[JoeMcKim]

I think that Descalso will be on the major league roster to start the season unless he completely drops the ball in ST.

[phins]

Anthony Garcia is one of the OF'er, Ehrlich is the C, tons of people for the RP, Tilson might be another of the OF'ers.

[JoeMcKim]

Is there something you see in Anthony Garcia as far as his potential once he does develop? I know he signed a contract young but he's been in rookie ball for 3 straight years now and his stats aren't that overpowering.

It looks like Garcia and Ehrlich are both about 3 years away from the majors.

[phins]

Is there something you see in Anthony Garcia as far as his potential once he does develop? I know he signed a contract young but he's been in rookie ball for 3 straight years now and his stats aren't that overpowering.

It looks like Garcia and Ehrlich are both about 3 years away from the majors.

Well, two years at the same level, and he's still young. If a wRC+ of 151 isn't overpowering stats, you have too high of expectations.

Just because they're far away doesn't make them not the best to me. I'm not too attached to Ehrlich (Cody Stanley could be the guy as well), but for now, I have Garcia there.