Page 3 of 11
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:32 pm
by WAR God
if the return is light, you’re literally better off keeping a player like Donovan. He actually does play the game the right way. Super high IQ.
I’d rather keep him around with the young guys for the next two seasons than ship him off for crap.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:33 pm
by jagtrader
Williamson is the only one checking his phone.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:35 pm
by jagtrader
What I've learned from this offseason is there is a percentage of very online Cardinals fans who do not give a [expletive] if the team has players worth watching this season.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:35 pm
by Lesson
WAR God wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:32 pm
if the return is light, you’re literally better off keeping a player like Donovan. He actually does play the game the right way. Super high IQ.
I’d rather keep him around with the young guys for the next two seasons than ship him off for crap.
Ownership, and by extension Bloom, are viewing the short term as not being a time to contend and not making any substantial investment in the roster (not saying this is the right approach, just that appears to be how they are operating). If that's the case, why hold onto a player who they probably won't extend and not get any return for someone who is under team control for a longer period of time?
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:39 pm
by phins
jagtrader wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:35 pm
What I've learned from this offseason is there is a percentage of very online Cardinals fans who do not give a [expletive] if the team has players worth watching this season.
If you hope to contend this year, I get the sentiment.
Cjinte is involved per the twitter and Joel Sherman.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:40 pm
by Famous Mortimer
phins wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:31 pm
Famous Mortimer wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:28 pm
I can't be bothered to gloat. Or feel chastened. Fans always overvalue their own team's guys, and it's boring to read about because it never materializes. That's all.
So your response is to be pedantic and abrasive?
And all you've done is try to gloat or call out. To the point I don't even want to engage with you.
Interesting strategy. It's your choice to do and that's fine, to be clear.
You brought it up. Several times, with no encouragement from me.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:41 pm
by Lesson
phins wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:39 pm
jagtrader wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:35 pm
What I've learned from this offseason is there is a percentage of very online Cardinals fans who do not give a [expletive] if the team has players worth watching this season.
If you hope to contend this year, I get the sentiment.
Cjinte is involved per the twitter and Joel Sherman.
Is there that much difference between a top 50 and 100 prospect?
Donovan is about to be 29 and under control for 2 more years. Realistically, based on aging curves, that will likely be the end or close to his prime, so not sure what the fuss is between that return.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:42 pm
by jagtrader
I haven't thought they could contend for years. But I don't want to watch Gorman bat anymore either. Can we have a happy medium?
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:43 pm
by WAR God
Lesson wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:35 pm
WAR God wrote: ↑February 2 26, 4:32 pm
if the return is light, you’re literally better off keeping a player like Donovan. He actually does play the game the right way. Super high IQ.
I’d rather keep him around with the young guys for the next two seasons than ship him off for crap.
Ownership, and by extension Bloom, are viewing the short term as not being a time to contend and not making any substantial investment in the roster (not saying this is the right approach, just that appears to be how they are operating). If that's the case, why hold onto a player who they probably won't extend and not get any return for someone who is under team control for a longer period of time?
At that point, why not shoot for zero wins and picking in the top three?
And to address the end of your passage, it’s because Donovan is fun to watch.
Winn, and who? Currently.
Re: Brendan Donovan to the Mariners deal is close (3 team trade with Rays)
Posted: February 2 26, 4:43 pm
by Mary1966
So a Cardinal who is an everyday player is going to Seattle. I can’t afford season tickets and I don’t think I would want to attend all the home games just for Donovan, but I might have to attend the home opener (if I can get a ticket for a reasonable price) just to welcome Donnie to Seattle.