Comparing Schenn and Faulk trades to themselves just for fun…
Sept 2019: Blues acquire 27 year old Justin Faulk and a 5th round pick for Joel Edmundson, Dominik Bokk and a 7th round pick.
https://www.nhl.com/blues/news/blues-ac ... -309425306
Mar 2026: Blues trade 33 year old Justin Faulk for a 1st round pick, a 3rd round pick Dimitri Buckelnikov, and Justin Holl.
https://www.nhl.com/blues/news/faulk-tr ... -2-players
Depending on who the Blues draft with the 1st, one could argue they (Blues) got a roughly equal return on a 33 year old Faulk than Carolina did on a 27 year old Faulk. Bokk was a highly touted (iirc) former first round prospect at the time, and I love Edmundson who was a former 2nd rounder who has had a nice career that fits well with a Dman drafted there.
The 1st rounder the Blues got this year will likely be right around where they picked Bokk at 25. (Maybe lower) Buckelnikov has a solid chance of being as good in value as Edmundson, though is boom or bust, and obviously a 3rd rounder is worth more than a 5th rounder. Holl is a cap dump and warm body whose contract expires at season’s end.
————
June 2017: Blues acquire 25 year old Brayden Schenn for Jori Lehtera, a 1st round pick (#27) and a conditional 2018 1st round pick (14th)
https://www.nhl.com/news/flyers-deal-br ... -290097928
Mar 2026: Blues trade 34 year old Brayden Schenn for a 1st round pick, 3rd round pick, Marcus Gidlof and Jonathan Drouin.
https://www.nhl.com/blues/news/blues-tr ... -islanders
The 2018 pick was 14, which is really good. The Blues paid more to acquire Schenn than to sell him, but its far closer than it should be. Lehtera was an absolute mess at that point with a horrible contract ($700k more than Drouin and one more year than Drouin!) Not to mention the difference in the % of cap - $75m cap in 2017 to $88m now and a big jump next year.
So the Blues cap dump at the time was a way bigger issue than Drouin now. Two first equal each other. So the difference is a 3rd round pick and a former 5th round goalie prospect with NHL upside vs another 1st.
You could squint and call it even ish value, except of course Schenn at 34 is a shadow of his 25 year old self.
————
The Blues did really well!
Also DA might be a wizard.